ADVENTURES IN CUSTOMER SERVICE – BEST BUY EMBRACES THE SUCK

by Betsy Wuebker on March 19, 2009

I bought my Netbook!

acerinhandSince Monday,  I’m the ecstatic owner of an Acer netbook!  This little baby has everything I need, and it’s tinier than the Filofax organizers we all used to carry around in the 1980’s!  Having my netbook is almost as great as having a small dog for people to exclaim and coo overEveryone who has seen it so far wants one.

Using my netbook has been easy, despite the dearth of documentation included in Acer’s so-called guides.  However, I can’t seem to get the netbook’s battery to charge – or if it is charged, it doesn’t reflect the status in the power meter.  I’ve already been on the Acer support page with the question and have been impressed with the prompt acknowledgment of my request for assistance.

Why wouldn’t I just take it back to Best Buy?

Well, that would seem the logical thing to do.  But I won’t, until I exhaust all other avenues.  Here’s why:  We practically had to beg Best Buy to buy this thing.

202px-bestbuy-2edmonton6748Now, the lack of, or maybe to be fair, spotty customer service at Best Buy is pretty much common knowledge. Knowing the head of the entire music division at their corporate headquarters never helped me get any better service out of their Ridgedale (Minnetonka) store – nor did it help said executive’s wife and family over the years, according to my Deephaven neighborhood’s lore.  You’d think they would’ve taken extra care with the boss’s family, right?  Nope.

We knew all this on Monday.  We had item numbers and pricing printed out from the web for exactly what we wanted to purchase.  Lured by the prospect of saving $20 over the competition, we entered Best Buy on a mission, ready to purchase.  This, you’d think, would be any blue-shirt nation citizen’s dream scenario.

Why do Best Buy systems and procedures suck the life out of customer experience?

Anyone who has been in sales for more than a minute knows this:   if a customer is buying, get the hell out of the way. This includes any obstacle – even someone who might be a member of your so-called team.  The hapless employee we beckoned had evidently missed class on the day this subject matter was covered.

acerboxThere was no Acer netbook on display.  There was one in a box, however, imprisoned in a wire cage below the display.  This cage was secured by a magnificent padlock for which, it seemed, no one had the key.  This struck me as a medieval system – sort of like the manor chatelaine who held the keyring as part of her duties running the household.

Once we had transcended the 3 levels or so in the hierarchy of the sales floor, an individual was located who could actually unlock the prison cell holding the inventory.  Now, with plenty of years in retailing, I’m fully aware of the need for on-floor measures against what we euphemistically termed as “shrinkage” back in the day.  But, truly, can’t you empower your employees to a level at which they could actually show a customer one of the products you’re trying to sell without having to scurry around like an idiot to access said product?  Just sayin’.

It was then that the Best Buy customer experience blasted into the orbit of the surreal.

202px-best_buy_logosvgThe aforementioned adolescent that we had successfully culled from the flock of blue-shirts proceeded to the computer department’s dedicated cash register.  With boxed computer in hand, he readied himself to punch keys.  We had yet to see our purchase from a distance of less than two feet.

“Hold it, ” Pete said as the youngster looked up, startled.  “We’d like to take a look at what we’re buying.”

We were handed the box in surprise.  We noted the price, though reflecting a discount, was different than that advertised on the web. When queried, our young man responded off-handedly, “Oh.” We waited for more.   After an uncomfortable pause, he added, “It must be a floor sample or something.”

“Maybe you could open the box so that we can see it, ” I chirped.

“Well, it’s really taped up,”  he responded.

“I know.  That’s why I want to see it, and perhaps you could tell me why it’s $10 more, even with the discount, than your online price.”  He took off with the still-boxed computer.

Teamwork reaches an entirely new level at Best Buy

A not much older young woman, dressed all in brown (no blue shirt to identify her?) was examining the box when we made our way over.  She looked over our printout and said, condescendingly, “This one has a different item number than the one online.”

Pete responded, “Well, it seems to me that we have the same features, the same memory, the same everything, except for an item number.  Shouldn’t the price be the same? What’s the difference, especially since this one has been opened and probably returned?”

“The difference is the item number.”  She looked at us like we were idiots. Oh.  Right.  It’s the same computer, down to the last specification, but the item number is the almighty arbiter.

“Why can’t you just knock the ten bucks off and sell it at your advertised price? It’s your last one, and clearly it’s been opened, or it’s been on display.”

“The discount has already been taken, you can see right here.  You’re already getting a fifty buck discount.”  Well, alrighty then.  Clearly, we were doddering fools in need of a drool cup. It must have been amazing that old codgers were even thinking of using a computer to begin with! Whatever.

So we proceed back to the checkout, and ask to see the computer outside of the box.  Would there be an electrical outlet so we could actually plug it in, and could we get it out of the plastic and open it up to physically experience the size of the keyboard?  Well, he supposed we could, but it was evident this was going above and beyond what our young man was prepared for.  He struggled a bit with the tape, valiantly stabbing at it with a pen.  I realized not only does Best Buy not trust the downstairs help with padlock keys:  Sharp objects that might be used for something as simple as getting a product out to demonstrate it to the customer must also be verboten.

The box came open.  He still seemed loathe to let me touch the netbook, however. Perhaps he thought I might not be gentle with it, much as we caution young children around baby animals and such?

Satisfied that the box did contain the desired item, and yes, it did power on, I quickly wrote the check, and we prepared our escape.  We still had to clear our receipt at the door while it was checked against our little parolee, but we’re used to that sort of thing.

Best Buy mistreats its customers

It’s not like we haven’t had crappy customer service at Best Buy in the past. But with the demise of Circuit City, there hasn’t been an alternative emerge to compete against their dominance in this town.  Home Depot has its Lowe’s, Office Max has its Office Depot and now Staples, we have choice in grocery items, but for computers – well, Best Buy is it in this town, except for Microcenter – which we patronize when Pete needs a Mac fix.

Some kids, I was told when one of mine was bullied in 3rd grade, just don’t realize that they shouldn’t even try to befriend an abuser.  Their strategy is to keep coming back for more, giving the bully an opportunity to strengthen the dysfunctional dynamic, and repeat the damage.

This is what played out with us on Monday.  Best Buy didn’t treat us with outright hostility.  They treated  us as if we were inconveniencing them by asking questions and wanting to see what we were buying.  That, friends, is a highly dysfunctional relationship with the customer.

A lousy customer service experience takes the joy out of having a new toy.

acerclosedDon’t get me wrong, I’m very happy with my little netbook.  It’s fun!  I love it!  But purchasing it from another retailer who actually gave a rat’s behind about the customer experience would have been so much nicer.

It’s not that hard to demand and train employees to uphold high customer service ethics, and to empower them to ensure their customer service is seamless, logical, and enjoyable.

Yo, Best Buy?  Next time, we’ll go elsewhere with our business.

Related:

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

{ 1 trackback }

Selfish Showerer
03.28.09 at 2:17 am

{ 18 comments… read them below or add one }

1

sean808080 03.19.09 at 8:52 am

I’m sorry you had to put up with that crap at Best Buy. You know what though? Best Buy is not alone in making the customer feel like they should take their business elsewhere. Even mom and pop stores that I would love to support sometimes put me through it.

Nonetheless…good choice on the Aspire one! I love mine and even blogged about the acer aspire one netbook here:

http://sean808080.com/blog/the-netbook-revolution-acer-aspire-one/

Enjoy!

sean808080´s last blog post..Remodelling is never done is it?

2

Betsy Wuebker 03.19.09 at 6:21 pm

Hi Sean – Your earlier recommendation sealed the deal with me. Yes, it’s unfortunate about the Best Buy experience, but I really like my netbook, so ultimately, it’s all good. Thanks.

3

Owen Lawson 03.20.09 at 3:07 pm

Betsy,

All these months, I thought it was just me. Best Buy never really spoke to me as a customer. I left Home Depot for the same reason.

Failure to listen to customers and listen clearly to what they are buying is the mother of all cancers for any business model. In your post, it strikes me that you were actually looking to purchase TRUST and technology…in just that order. What was the cost of Best Buy’s not listening…well they just contributed to CGM without even putting in a to do list. Consumer Generated Media offers real power to customers looking to amplify their voice…it can spread the drugs that keep Cancer at bay or it can accelerate the spread of cancer. The Enterprise makes the decision about the role of the CGM vehicle by demonstrating it’s ability to listen to it’s customers.

Excellent post…thank you for empowering CGM and thank you for helping me to feel better about a recent recommendation for my father regarding purchasing a Netbook.

4

Rich and Tauron 03.20.09 at 4:25 pm

Your netbook blog is very entertaining Betsy, and unfortunately true!! Inspite of your unpleasant experience, know you will enjoy your new toy.
Rich says,They don’t call him DICK Schultz for nothing!!!! And oh by the way, if you wanted to return it , now that it has been opened again, they will want to charge you a 15% restocking fee!

5

Betsy Wuebker 03.20.09 at 5:19 pm

Hi Owen – Welcome! Wouldn’t you think that, in a recession, stores would be all over ensuring the best customer service experience? This has to be a conscious decision on some level not to, as you say. Thank you.

Hi Rich and Tauron – Welcome to the comment section. Experiences like this just makes you want to fume! Payback is a blog post that might show up on a search engine. And you’re right – they probably got 15% already off this computer, and would have ultimately recouped 30% had I returned it to them a second time. Thanks!

6

Ben 03.22.09 at 4:29 am

‘Clearly, we were doddering fools in need of a drool cup.’

hahaha

7

Cath Lawson 03.24.09 at 11:26 am

Hi Betsy, I’m glad you finally got your Netbook but that sounds like a really sucky store. I hope places like that go under in the recession to make room for smaller businesses who actually give a toss.

And I hope you get the problem sorted. A laptop that won’t hold it’s charge is pretty useless. I have to wonder if that isn’t why the last customer took it back.

I’m guess they must have charged you the extra 10 bucks for all that tape that was holding the box together.

8

Betsy Wuebker 03.24.09 at 7:03 pm

Hi Ben – I probably should’ve swung my old lady purse at ‘em, eh? :)

Hi Cath – Best Buy got helped by another large chain’s bankruptcy recently. Now they’re the main game. Yeah, ten bucks for tape! LOL Thanks.

9

lizriz 03.29.09 at 10:44 am

I went through the exact same thing while buying external drives at Best Buy, right down to when they finally get it out of the cage, you can’t touch it to look at it, read it, and see if it’s what you want to buy. Insane.

lizriz´s last blog post..Relationships Teach You Many Things.

10

Sarah 03.30.09 at 3:13 pm

Hi Betsy,

I’m Sarah, one of Best Buy’s online community agents. We frequently review online postings to assist individuals with their technical issues.

In doing so, I came across your post and while it does not appear to be a technical issue, as you state you are very happy with the Netbook itself, I do sincerely apologize for the poor experience you had in our Minnetonka location when making your purchase.

We hope to provide our customers with great shopping experiences that they can brag about and we take feedback such as this very seriously. Therefore, I will be forwarding the information you have provided to the appropriate supervisors and management teams so that the situation may continue to be reviewed for improvement opportunities.

I also hope that if you choose to give our Minnetonka location another chance in the future, you will receive much better service and know that you helped to make that difference!

Sincerely,
Sarah
Best Buy Community Connector
http://forums.bestbuy.com

11

Betsy Wuebker 04.01.09 at 9:11 am

Hi lizriz – Welcome to PassingThru! Yes, I think it’s insane that a potential customer isn’t allowed access to the merchandise they are buying! While it’s understandable that a floor sample would handle that job nicely, if there isn’t one, what is a customer supposed to do? Crazy! Thanks for coming by!

Hi Sarah – Welcome to PassingThru! Thank you for taking the initiative to respond, and I appreciate that you will forward this cautionary tale to the Minnetonka store. However, the Minnetonka store is not the only Best Buy location that has been notorious for lo, these many years, in delivering similar abysmal service levels. It makes you wonder about how expectations are set and communicated to store employees, and whether the customer is truly a priority when it comes to the day-to-day in store operations for Best Buy.

Quite honestly, mentioning that you’ll send this along doesn’t provide much incentive toward giving the store another chance when there’s such longevity of negative experience. When there is little choice for consumers in a market, these concepts don’t matter much to merchants. When employees aren’t empowered, or are constrained by ignorance (entirely possible with our young employee) or store policy (more likely), it matters even less to them. In recessionary times, the businesses that deliver an exceptionally great experience are going to be the ones that get the consumer’s precious dollars.

I’ve been training franchisees for years on how to develop and maintain long-term, high dollar volume relationships with customers. I’d be curious to know what training methods and programs are currently in place and what the expectations really are for store employees in meeting customer service standards. And, I’d be willing to offer my expertise in these areas to Best Buy, as well.

I sold my BBY stock when it was in the $50’s years ago. To my knowledge it’s never been close to that in the last several years before the market tanked. Your company has an awesome opportunity to surge ahead and dominate in this economy. But store policies are going to blow that opportunity if no changes are made.

Thank you again for your sincere response. I’d be happy to take things further with you or any representative of your company privately, if desired.

12

Dot 04.10.09 at 12:37 pm

“We frequently review online postings to assist individuals with their technical issues.” Doesn’t that translate into English as, “We search blogs for bad press for BB and try to counteract it”? I had almost the exact same experience when I bought a combination VCR/DVD player. When I inquired about the lack of a remote, someone dug out a big cardboard box full of things tossed in together. They dug around and found a remote, then took the batteries from another item and put them in the remote. It was a good deal, but I much prefer to shop online.

Dot´s last blog post..All About Chocolate

13

Betsy Wuebker 04.11.09 at 11:07 am

Hi Dot – LOL you are a good translator! Assisting me with my issue would be inducing the store manager to contact me and have a conversation about what can be done about the experience. Nice experience with the remote for you – NOT! Jeez. At least when you shop online, you can be assured that the item you purchase is most probably new. Thanks.

14

rob 04.24.09 at 2:17 pm

Well as for the item number being different it means a lot. Much of the stock at best buy is marked down specifically on item number and time on shelf. Laptops and note books usually have less than 10% margin in them. so it is possible you were getting it for lose to cost or less. Not to mention some dealers credit back marked down items to the vendor hence why they were marked down. Bad service is no excuse. However they don’t want to actually get less than cost on the item. I have found though that when the consumer is the expert on a rare item the frequently get sub-par service. Because the item so unknown many people at the retail site don’t know anything about it.

15

rob 04.24.09 at 2:22 pm

Opening the box to check the contents if there is no physical damage on the outside make it to where the retailer has to take a mark down on the “open box item”. You have 14 days to return most purchases so needing to open the box in the store if its factory sealed and free from external damage is a moot point.

16

Pete 04.24.09 at 6:29 pm

It seems to me that the customer experience is what all sales are about regardless on how much you make on the sale. A good customer experience generates both repeat sales and word of mouth support (The strongest kind). If you can’t afford to sell it, then why carry it. Every sale should generate some positive customer response. It didn’t even take the walk to the car to realize that we would not want to go through this again.

In going back over the original post, it was not entirely clear that this was a returned item. The reference to the tape was about that. Clearly it was resealed. As such Best Buy had made 10% merely for allowing the customer to return the item. They are so generous.

Further, if an item is on display so one can make a final decision, then yes it is a moot point. In this instance however, not only was there no model on display but only through the customer’s persistence were we able to get the worker bee to check behind the bars to see if one of the mystery boxes might be what we had come in for. By golly, the customer was right again.

Pete´s last blog post..THOSE ODIOUS MISCREANTS AND DETESTABLE TOOLS

17

brothmark 07.06.09 at 8:18 am

I liek the Best store the items they have but I agree the customer serivce is bad. I used to like shoping at Home Depot too but customer service drove me away.

18

Betsy Wuebker 07.07.09 at 10:51 am

Hi brothmark – I agree that the customer service experience has suffered at both stores. Thanks.

Leave a Comment

You can use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

CommentLuv Enabled
UA-9789083-1