After 18 months more than three years of full-time travel with both checked and carry on bags, our ideas about packing and which luggage is best for travel might surprise you!
Which luggage is best for travel and how can travelers maximize packing space? We’ve been to more than 30 40 countries in the past two three years, and have dragged our belongings along in a variety of ways. Some of the initial choices we made, to be brutally honest, were just awful. We were so dumb! But, we’ve hit some winners after numerous false starts at combining products for the best travel luggage set of suitcases and carry on bags. We’ve had a couple of dreadful fails and so much of trial and error.
We’ve decided to share recommended examples which we hope might help you in your own decision-making. And, if this inspires you to shop – even if it’s just for more information, click on any of our affiliate links below to be taken directly to Amazon.
This post contains affiliate links and/or references to our advertisers. We may receive compensation when you click on or make a purchase using these links.
First: Scrap the Spinner Bag
Trolley wheels! No, no, NO!
Who hasn’t schlepped heavy stuff in an interminably long slog to the farthest gate, only to encounter a blithe spirit effortlessly gliding a swift and stylish spinner bag along? We hated those people! We had spinner envy! So, when Pete’s first suitcase got ratty enough, we ditched it in Istanbul and bought a bright red, expander bag with spinning trolley wheels off a no-name shopkeeper. We were going to OWN the baggage claim area with this bag. And yes, sure enough, we could definitely spot it coming off every carousel! But our win was short-lived: what also came off within a couple of flights was one of the wheels! Plus, who leaves room in their luggage? You’re going to fill that bad boy up, aren’t you? Do this, and you’ll have not a spinner, but a toppler. You’ll still be a schlepper. The only bright and stylish spinner you might want to consider would be a hard case which will balance, but they weigh a lot more. And, you’ve still got the trolley wheel problem. Trust us, think hard about using a spinner bag for the long haul, no matter how awesome it looks.
This bag is cabin-approved, aerospace grade polycarbonate in a beautiful selection of colors, with an interior organization system that will keep your belongings shipshape. Chester offers a 30-day no-hassle return policy, and a 10-year warranty on this bag.
PassingThru readers get a 10% discount and free two-day shipping on the Chester website, use code PT10. Click here for more information and pricing on this lightweight carry on luggage.
This bag is also available on Amazon in all colors. If you’d rather purchase from Amazon, click here.
Next: Recognize the Right Kind of Roller Bag
For our money – and we’ve spent a sufficient amount on the wrong luggage to be right about this – a roller with in-line wheels is the way to go. This type of wheel is recessed, which protects and makes it a challenge to damage. Pete bought a large expandable bag with these kind of wheels to replace the ill-fated Istanbul spinner when we got to Bangkok, and it performed so well we went back and each got a carry-on size. The following bags by Delsey boast all the must-have details: one-hand locking handle and protected recessed wheels glide smoothly, roomy expansion when unzipped adds more depth to the bag, exterior pockets keep items you need handy.
These two items are the same fabulous bag, just in different sizes. Love the purple, don’t you?
If you’re a light traveler, and many of our peers who prefer not to hassle with baggage claim are, you’ll want to check out this two piece carry-on set from Delsey. This is probably the best travel luggage set I’ve seen according to the parameters we’ve set. The smaller underseat bag has a handy trolley sleeve for stacking on top of the larger roller.
So Pete’s all set with his burly roller bags, and since this post was originally written, now so am I. (See my full review of the Delsey Montsouris I’m currently using here). The large rolling duffle bag I started with at the beginning of this journey is still going strong, just with another owner who was pleased to get it as a hand-me-down. This duffle is a winner for a couple of reasons:
- It’s divided into two separate areas with a full horizontal zipper. This means I could access frequently used items without disturbing other contents. So dressier or alternate climate clothing went below and stayed packed until needed.
- Its soft sides and pockets were versatile spaces for items of varying size. I often used one for small amounts of laundry, and another for an extra pair of flip flops or a sarong, which can double as a wrap or a travel blanket.
This rugged, yet stylish duffle from Pathfinder is very similar to the one that I’ve been using going into a second year. It’s got the inline wheels, telescoping handle with an ergonomic grip, and a bit more infrastructure in the top compartment than mine. Web hauling straps and an additional handle are very helpful when you need an assist boarding your train or hoisting into an overhead shelf. Pathfinder makes this in different sizes depending upon your needs.
But wait! Don’t Overlook Vera Bradley Luggage
But there’s another part of our overall experience that relates to the question of which luggage is best for travel. Up until the point of purchasing the wheeled carry on like the ones above, I’d been using an attractive Vera Bradley print weekender bag, along with a matching laptop attache for my technology. Vera Bradley travel bags are nearly weightless and the washable fabric is perfect for carryon because it’s pliable – easily stuffed into an overhead bin or under the seat.
The new Weekender is redesigned with a trolley sleeve.
The drawback to my Vera Bradley travel bag system was having to carry them through airport and customs security lines. Carts aren’t always available or allowed in these areas. So I reluctantly accepted the change to a plain roller. If I had the chance to start completely over, though, I’d look at creating a Vera Bradley luggage set again.
Old favorites like my Weekender have been redesigned into newer versions of themselves with convenient infrastructure: multiple pockets and built-in trolley sleeves. There is even a new double-compartment wheeled carry on which is similar to the duffel style above. And who doesn’t love a complementary Vera Bradley travel tote?
1. Vera Bradley Grand Traveler Tote has a little more structure but still pliable. It is a roomy 21 x 14-1/2 x 9-1/2 with removable strap and trolley sleeve, two slip pockets in back and one large pocket under the front magnetic flap on the outside. Inside there are four large slip pockets. This bag would work for technology if you use a padded laptop sleeve. If you don’t mind shouldering what could be a heavy bag when it’s packed full, this Vera Bradley carry on luggage option would definitely suit for many different kinds of trips.
2. Vera Bradley Lighten Up Wheeled Carry On is 21 x 14 x 9-3/4 in water resistant poly fabric. Inside the front zip-around pocket there are a zip and two mesh pockets. The lower compartment is separate from the top compartment, which has compression straps. Vera Bradley wheeled luggage is relatively new on the scene, and initially only came in black. Who wants that out of Vera Bradley? But, happy to see in the last couple of seasons, they’ve expanded the patterns available.
3. Vera Bradley Weekender is now improved with a trolley sleeve and removable strap. This bag comes in at 18-1/2 x 12-1/2 x 8, easily fits underneath an airplane seat. Five inner pockets for smaller items, fully zippered front compartment and two back slip pockets.
Pick Packing Cubes for an Organizational Win
No matter your decision on which luggage is best for travel, organizing your stuff inside can be an ongoing challenge. In packing clothing, there are generally two camps: folders and rollers. We’re both rollers, as we’ve tested the two methods and it’s clear you save more space when you roll clothing. As well, you get fewer wrinkles. But that said, we diverge a bit because I am a huge fan of packing cubes. Pete, not so much (if I could only get him to try them I think he’d be hooked, but I digress).
The advantage to packing cubes is not having to handle each item. Instead, you’re handling clusters of items when you unpack. If you don’t unpack, then you’re not digging through everything in your suitcase to find the one item you want. So like items go into their cube. I’m using two separate sets: a set of 3 and a set of 3 slim size. If you’re new to packing cubes, you might want to consider the set of 6. Even if you don’t use them all on your trip, you can find an organizational use for them at home.
1. 6-piece Packing Cube Set from NDX Global. Two each of large and medium, one small and a shoe bag. Double toggle zip with mesh inserts for easy viewing. Strong nylon fabric and foldable handle.
2. 3 piece Weekender Packing Cube Set. Small, medium and large cubes. Small is good for scarves and socks. I use the medium for swimsuits, sarongs and coverups. Large holds bulkier items like jeans, dresses and jackets.
3. 3 piece Slim Packing Cube Set. Versatile size for undies, tank tops or tees. Tuck into unused suitcase space, or stack vertically.
Best Jewelry and Cosmetic Organizers
Finally, I have to share the winning combination for organizing jewelry and cosmetics. These three items have carried me through thick and thin. One of the things I didn’t want was to feel deprived of favorite pieces of costume jewelry, which does so much to liven up a minimalist wardrobe. Likewise, we all have our favorite cosmetics and toiletries. Keeping things organized is reassuring and saves time. 
1. PurseN Tiara Square Jewelry Case with interior pouches. This little soft box is like an origami puzzle. Multiple clear zip pouches separate your jewelry into easy to see groups, and fold in on one another, squared up in an zip expandable case. Comes in 16 colors. Pops into odd space, and holds a lot!
2. Travel Jewelry Case. This is another great find. At first, I thought it might be too small, but there are bracelet holders, earring display, and interior pouches. You’ll be surprised at what fits in this little bag. Easily tucks into a purse or briefcase.
3. Vera Bradley Hanging Organizer. One of the first things I do in a new hotel room is hang this organizer in the bathroom. When it’s open I can see everything at a glance. Compartments are lined with waterproofing. The bottom zip pocket is gusseted and holds a lot. The top pocket has slip sections for organizing within. Ties closed with carry handles. This is such a great organizer that we’ve given it to all three of our girls – it makes a great gift!
For more great ideas, check out the Travel Essentials section in PassingThru’s Amazon Store.
We hope you find this discussion of packing options and which luggage is best for travel has been helpful. It’s going in our new Travel Shop section here at PassingThru. We’ll be adding to it in the coming weeks, too. As always, your reactions and suggestions help us to refine what we include, so let us know what you think in the comments!
Pinnable Images:
PassingThru is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com, amazon.co.uk, amazon.ca. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates.
To view PassingThru’s privacy policy, click here.
Travel gear that really works is a perennial issue, and I can definitely vouch (anti-vouch?) for spindly spinning wheels being a disaster waiting to happen. When I’m ready to spring for new luggage, will certainly take a look at these various options, especially the two-tier duffle. So many choices, thanks for these suggestions, Betsy!
Hi Anita – Yes, I am constantly interested in luggage and bags, even if I don’t “need” any. The two-tier duffle style is definitely a winner for me.
The latest object of my luggage affection is a 2O inch Lucas spinner wheel soft sided suitcase. I haven’t had a problem with the wheels although admittedly, I’m careful on cobblestones. Things I love about it:
1) It doesn’t tip over. (My in line 2 wheelers always did).
2) It’s light enough that little ol’ me can carry it up and down metro stairs when necessary. I can still use some help hoisting it into overhead bins. This is where my best pathetic face (followed by effusive thanking) comes in handy.
3) It holds an amazing amount. I love the tie downs. My clothes come out looking ironed. (I can see the value of packing cubes for not having to root through an entire suitcase looking for one thing).
4) Because of the spinners, I can push it ahead of me with the narrow side forward down a train or plane aisle.
5) I totally concur with your appreciation of a hanging toiletry bag. It makes lack of bathroom shelf space a non-issue. Mr. Excitement and I share one.
Hi Suzanne – I envy you the spinner, and I would totally consider one if I could guarantee I’d never check the bag with an airline. You’re right about pushing it ahead of you in aisles being easier than dragging it behind. Cobblestones would give me pause. But I won’t get one after losing a wheel; even dragging the 3-wheel bag was just about impossible, and soooo frustrating as it happened in airport #3 after buying it.
I do like the jewelry organizers; I’ll have to consider replacing my ancient traveling case. It is fun to see how we’ve changed over to new luggage over the years. Now my roller is an Eagle Creek carry-on size, super light, and my carry-on is a Patagonia soft bag that works as a backpack – for my electronics and toiletries and sundries.
Hi Kristin – I think you’d like the jewelry cases above a lot. I certainly do. Luggage and systems are very personal, but those two items rise above any conceivable limitations.
I too had an ISTANBUL spinner/TOPPLER. It was the LUCAS carry on. I wrote to them and they sent some double wheels to put on and it didn’t TOPPLE on my last trip. I’m also a HUGE fan of packing cubes, but my husband (the disorganized one) doesn’t understand the concept. How could he? It would imply he liked being organized.
Hi Vicki – If I recall correctly, our no-name toppler had double wheels. It was a question of expanding it to the point where balance was compromised. I haven’t seen anyone yet who has tried packing cubes not love them. The challenge is getting “some people” to try. 🙂
I bought my first Delsey in India and it went well over 100,000 miles with me through many years of back and forth between the US and India. I LOVED it. But I hated that it was a spinner wheels bag which meant that I had to lay it totally flat to open it all the way. I have packed that thing so many times I know exactly how full I can pack it without going over the 23k max, that I just can’t bare to trade it in for a newer one! These days I’ve become in love with my Ebags motherlode 21 inch carryon. I can fit so much stuff in it that I rarely have to check a bag these days. Now what I need is a better system of carrying my toiletries and several pairs of shoes so they don’t take up so much space 🙂
Hi Karilyn – Yes, the Delseys are really rugged, aren’t they? And yes, toiletries and shoes are the big space hogs for me, too. I fixed the shoe part by trying to stay in warmer climates. Flip-flops pack flat. 😉
Great post because I am constantly on the lookout for the “perfect” bag. Your first item about spinner caught my attention because I totally agree. I don’t have a spinner and am not interested in getting one. Two wheels is fine for me. I have TRIED to like packing cubes but just can’t. I find I get more in my bag rolling my clothes. I know I am losing out on keeping things better organized, but I guess I prefer adding “just one more item” (which is bad).
Hi Janice – I can’t resist looking at all kinds of bags, either. And yes, there are two camps with regard to the packing cubes, those who swear by them and those who don’t like them at all. 🙂
Having been someone who has also made many “dumb” luggage picks, I appreciated your insights which will guide my next suitcase decision.
Hi Caryn – Glad we could help! It’s knowledge hard won, that’s for sure!
Thanks for the overview! When I’m ready for a new carry-on, that Vera Bradley looks perfect for shorter trips! I was really happy with an Eagle Creek 20-liter wheeled backpack on my long solo trips this past year. I was able to carry it on, even though it was an inch or so over the official carry-on size. And when my path was too rough or steep for wheeling it, I could convert it to a very comfortable backpack and carry it. And it forced me to travel light!
Hi Rachel – I love Vera Bradley prints. They just liven things up with personality, and for shorter trips where you don’t need to check a bag, they’re perfect! You’re right that limiting your bag size ensures you’ll travel light.
Great information! Do the recessed wheels take up interior space? I’ve fallen in love with my hard-sided luggage because it’s weatherproof and light.
Hi Irene – I don’t really think the wheels inhibit interior space that much. The packing cubes just sort of mold around the small indentations the wheels make. And yes, I like the look of hardsided luggage, too, but the only thing I seem to see is the spinner wheels with them and those are a deal breaker for me. 🙂
We too have bought and ditched some bags along the way. I currently use an inline wheel bag (not as nice as yours). I’ve had it for nine years so it can no longer be used as a carry-on but I actually like putting my main bag in the hold now that the seats are so tight. I use my small backpack for a carry on but if it ever wears out I would like to find a backpack that has a trolley sleeve as I like to be able to have my hands free but would also like to not carry it if possible. I do use packing cubes… one for laundry, one for socks and underwear and I couldn’t travel without my hanging organizer. I now leave travel size items in it so that it’s ready to go.
My favourite story about bags happened in Bangkok. We had been traveling for three months and realized that we were tired of schlepping so much stuff from place to place. We decided that we could and should wear fewer items and that no one would notice as we were in a different place fairly quickly. (My green skirt had been photographed in a lot of different countries). We packed a bag of stuff we thought we wouldn’t need including a camera. After taping the box up with a tonne of tape we went to the post office and sent it off. As we walked away we said, “Well, we can kiss that stuff goodbye, it will never make it home.” and started to laugh. It did make it home. It took two months but it was there waiting for us when we finally got back. We didn’t miss anything in that box. Lesson learned. In fact, it was a lesson I’ve applied to my life back home. I own way less clothes now than I used to! Only once did a student ask my why I usually wore black and green and how long had I had my jacket and he was interested in the answer.
Hi Nina – Isn’t it amazing the lengths we’ll go to keep stuff we wind up never missing? I’m guilty of the same thing: we sent winter clothes home to Minnesota a couple years ago. I find myself looking at photos and wondering if we ever make it back there, did I keep that sweater? hahaha Your story about the green skirt reminds me of my green dress. A couple of posts back, we did a summary of a year’s worth of travel and I’m wearing the same green dress in each photo. 😀
Hmm…. interesting post. I’m totally in love with my spinner bags and have travelled extensively with them. The only problem I’ve had with my Samsonite luggage was my recent trip to Indonesia, even though my bag is equipped with TSA locks the airport staff ripped the zippers open for inspection purposes. At least they didn’t put any drugs in there which apparently is a big worry in the area!
I have an injured shoulder so I find that a two wheel bag tends to niggle at my injury.
Hi Elaina – There are lots of people who love their spinner bags. We wanted to be among them, but when the trolley wheel gets torn off on their third flight rendering the bag unusable, we don’t love it so much anymore. It’s pretty easy to breach a luggage zipper with a pen – I think there might be a youtube showing how it’s done out there. That’s a pretty scary proposition. :-/
Hi, Love my spinner bags they are by Samantha Brown, I have traveled locally and oversea
and have not had any problem…also a fan of the packing cubes so i’m not digging through my bag for clothes.